VFP Logo Rogue Valley Veterans For Peace
usaflag Chapter 156 peaceflag

The pursuit of happiness requires that we work for peace,
because peace and happiness are not separable.

Menu


Home

About Us

Activities

News/Info

THIS PAGE IS:
The Costs of War

National & OR political contacts

Nuc Wpns Accidents

Nuc Wpns Abolition

Depleted Uranium


Straight Talk on Military Recruitment

Opting Out

The Contract,
the current
DD Form 4

(.pdf format)


Before You Enlist

Alternatives

G.I. Rights

Senior Vet Health Care

External Links


Banner



The Costs of War

NEW: In approximately the last century, the American public has been exposed to a perception management situation concerning the "glamor" of battle and of war, without regard to consideration of ALL the costs of war. This '.pdf' shows what U.S. taxpayers are supporting compared to other countries in the world. From the National Priorities Project (details), taxpayers in Rogue Valley, OR (Jackson and Josephine Counties), up to July 27, 2010, have paid $540.1 million, total, for the Iraq and Afghanistan war spending since 2001, and are continuing to pay. For the same amount of money, to that date, the following could have been provided:

129,169 People Receiving Low-Income Healthcare for One Year OR
7,812 Police or Sheriff's Patrol Officers for One Year OR
8,743 Firefighters for One Year OR
74,703 Scholarships for University Students for One Year OR
97,331 Students receiving Pell Grants of $5550 OR
270,769 Children Receiving Low-Income Healthcare for One Year OR
97,393 Head Start Slots for Children for One Year OR
109,687 Households with Renewable Electricity - Solar Photovoltaic for One Year OR
8,557 Elementary School Teachers for One Year OR
292,498 Households with Renewable Electricity-Wind Power for One Year

Yet, these figures are only addressing the first two categories (A1 and A2) of the list below.


So, what are these Costs of War?
They generally comprise:

(A) the obvious financial costs, consisting of

(1) Operations - equipment, logistics, etc. (This is the figure that is used in the chart below - see link at "Notes2". However, a recent study for the Iraq war indicates that, taking the below factors into acount, the figure shown in the chart, of ~$860B, was being projected to be over $2T per an NPR, Day to Day, January 13, 2006 article, but can easily be closer to over $3.5T per a November 13, 2008 posting!!!)

(2) Overhead - active duty personnel (including basic equipment), etc.

(3) Inflation costs (for a protracted war, for which, for example, there was no advanced Congressional funding).
(4) Health care (for active duty and the wounded).

(5) Getting back to a pre-war capability (equipment replacement).

(6) Social Security, retiree pay, disability payments. (Note that the chart below primarily addresses the physically wounded, but not the mental/psychological impacts, or the resulting suicides1.)

(7) Interest on borrowed money (similar to (4), above).

(8) Costs to society (Financial and emotional impacts).

(9) Diverted resources from the economy (Temporary - We take the most physically and mentally fit to do military duty... Permanent - a percentage of which do not return in that capacity).

(10) Environmental - The rebuilding of damaged or obliterated infrastructure, facilities (water, sewer, roads, bridges, power) and even economies of the participants and "innocent victims"... our page dealing with depleted uranium is a prime example of this as a more "modern-day-warfare" problem. (Also witness the U.S. Marshall Plan after WWII, when we helped Germany and Japan rebuild... then they were later able to do our own economy and manufacturing capabilities tremendous damage when they could then produce goods better and cheaper because of the newer technologies they had been equipped with. We feel this effect to this day as our - now stunted - manufacturing capabilities were encouraged to go abroad.)

(B) the diplomatic costs with our allies and non-aligned nations (as we have all seen with the uncalled-for Iraq war engineered by the Bush/Cheney administration), followed by a totally inept attempt at nation-building and establishing a U.S. style democracy without any understanding of the region or culture.

(C) the human costs on its participants and our citizens (NO army throughout time has been immune to the testosterone of combat training and the appeal to our individual lower nature, which often results in atrocities to civilian populations in the combat zones... or to a perceived foe... and can often result in a person "living with himself" later, whether on the giving or receiving end of a particular incident), and which can contribute to

(D) the longer-term human costs of caring for the physically and psychologically injured of both sides.

Considering that the overwhelming casualities of war are civilians, war is the wrong answer.

War = Terrorism "Agreement is less important than respect, for with respect agreement may one day occur, but without it agreement is impossible. Honesty and openness will earn you respect."
…
"There are no winners in violent confrontation, only loser - and more losers."

The Tenth Millennium, Ken Carey, Harper Collins, NY, 1991

"Instead of romanticizing militarism, it might be time for a more realistic look at the underlying motivations and horrible consequences of war." Tedi Elliott, writing for The Bleeping Herald, Vol. 4 Issue 2, June, 2008 (http://www.bleepingherald.com/jun2008/addicted-to-war). This Chapter wholeheartedly agrees, and is listing some hard-hitting resources, below, along this line:

  • Mark Twain wrote The War Prayer in 1904 and it is just as true today as "back then."

  • Here is a short booklet written by a Marine Corp. General of WWI that, again, is just as true today, as it was in his day, War is a Racket War is a Racket, by General Smedley D. Butler.

  • And here is another very strong critique in the same vein, but from a current generation of very knowledgeable officers. This presentation is strongly religious, while addressing U.S. war-making rationale in a very analytical manner: Making War: Implications for both Church and State Policy of Christian Theology, International Law, and the Constitution.

  • For an all-inclusive review of this same situation in an easy-to-read format, look at "Addicted to War," by Joel Andreas. This is a hard-hitting comic-book version expose of U.S. history that you won't find in our standard school textbooks. It can be ordered from http://www.addictedtowar.com/bookbulk.html, or read it on-line for free.

  • Then there's a hard-hitting 2-hour DVD/video compilation, "What I’ve Learned About U.S. Foreign Policy: The War Against The Third World," by Frank Dorrel, with a 37-page transcript in MS Word here (Note his copyright assignment: "THIS DVD IS ANTI-COPYRIGHTED. PLEASE COPY AND DISTRIBUTE FREELY").

  • Ray McGovern was a mid-level officer in the CIA in the 1960s where his focus was analysis of Soviet policy toward Vietnam. McGovern was one of President Ronald Reagan's intelligence briefers from 1981-85; he was in charge of preparing daily security briefs for Reagan, Vice President George H.W. Bush, the National Security Advisor, the Joint Chiefs of Staff, and the Cabinet. Later, McGovern was one of several senior CIA analysts who prepared the President's Daily Brief (PDB) during the first Bush administration. Upon retirement, McGovern was awarded the Intelligence Commendation Medal from Bush (which he later returned, see below) and worked for Washington-based non-profits before becoming co-director of the Servant Leadership School in Washington. (Above, from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ray_McGovern)
    Although this ".pdf" piece by McGovern addresses problems with the CIA, the general theme readily supports other writers in this group.

  • These quotes are from "What Every Person Should Know About War," Chris Hedges, Free Press, N.Y., 2003: "We ennoble war. We turn it into entertainment. And in all this we forget what war is about, what it does to those who wage it and those who suffer from it. We ask those in the military and their families to make sacrifices that color the rest of their lives. Those who hate war the most, I have often found, are veterans who know it."

    "In the 1990s, civilian deaths constituted between 75 and 90 percent of all war deaths."

    "The military will condition you to act based on your orders, not on your conscience."

    "One Army survey of 55,000 soldiers at 47 bases showed that one of every three families has suffered some kind of domestic violence, from slapping to murder. This is twice the rate found in similar groups of civilians. The Pentagon has disclosed that an average of one child or spouse dies each week at the hands of a relative in the military."
  • A Book Reference List - Here are some other references for those that might be interested in challenging their concept of what alternative histories and war is all about...

    • "A People's History of the United States," Howard Zinn - presenting U.S. history as it was never taught in our schools... including the many the deceptions our government has played on the American public (a "broader statement" than the book below).

    • "A Tale of Two Quagmires," Kenneth Campell - Comparing Iraq and Vietnam, the hard lessons of war and the deceptions of the American public.

    • "Blowback - The Costs and Consequences of American Empire," Chalmers Johnson - refers to the unintended consequences of American meddling in other countries' internal affairs and destinies.

    • "Exile," R.N. Patterson - a story of the hardships faced daily in Palistine

    • "Support The Truth," Dennis Kyne - An insider's look at the U.S. using WMD in the Middle East.

    • "The Good Soldiers," David Finkel - an embedded reporter's observations in Iraq.

    • "The Will to Resist," Dahr Jamil - a classic.

    • "Winter Soldier," various contributors - discussing what really goes on in the Middle East wars.

    • "Rules of Disengagement," Cohn & Gilbred - describing the virtually daily variability of the supposedly "solid" Rules of Engagement in Iraq.

    • "The Unmaking of a Marine," Tyler E. Boudreau - written by a Marine Captain on the war in Iraq.

    • "Replacing The Warrior," William Myers - although just a 31-page pamphlet, there's a hidden revelation of the effects of automation as being introduced in modern warfare.

    • "Beyond the Green Zone," Dahr Jamail - conditions beyond the protected administrative center of Baghdad

    • "On Killing," L/C Grossman - a classic, written by a former West Point professor.

    • "My Navy Too," Beth F. Coye, Commander, U.S. Navy (Ret.)

    • "Lessons in Disaster, McGeorge Bundy and the Path to War in Vietnam," Gordon Goldstein

    • "Confessions of an Economic Hit Man," John Perkins

    • Various works of Stephen Walt (whether you might agree with him, or not) * The Israel Lobby and U.S. Foreign Policy (2007)
      * Taming American Power (2005)
      * Revolution and War (1996)
      * The Origins of Alliances (1987)


CHART: Military casualties suffered by the
United States of America in war or deployments.

This is a modified & abbreviated chart from Wikipedia.
Additional research is needed (if available) to fill in the blank spaces, beyond
DoD_Numbers_Who_Served.pdf and VA's War Statistics.doc.

NOTE that the chart below, of 47 conflicts (for, on average, a war every 5/1/2 years), IS NOT a complete list of wars the U.S has engaged in and that Congress, per our Constitution, has only declared war five times in our history, for the War of 1812, Mexican-American War, the Spanish-American War, WWI and WWII.

NEW: This report lists 234 instances in which the United States has used its armed forces abroad in situations of conflict, or potential conflict, or for other than normal peacetime purposes (there is redundancy with the chart below). This is a "sanitized" version for Congress and doesn't address the commercial interests that were behind the vast majority of these actions, nor does it address clandestine activities such as the CIA has engaged in to engender the term "blowback," (see booklist above for a title by that name).

War or conflict Date Number
Serving
Deaths Wounded1 Missing $ Costs of
War2,3,4
combat other total
American Revolutionary War5 1775–1783 217,000 8,000 17,000 25,000 25,000 - 101M, 1,825M
Quasi-War 1798–1800 - 20 - 20 42 - -
Barbary Wars 1801–1815 - - 35 - 35 - -
Other actions against pirates 1800–1900 - 10 - 10 21 - -
Northwest Indian War 1785–1795 - 1221+ - - 458 3 -
War of 1812 1812–1815 286,730 2,260 ~17,000 ~20,000 4,505 - 90M, 1,177M
First Seminole War 1817–1818 - 30 - 30 - - -
Black Hawk War 1832 - 60+ - - - - -
Second Seminole War 1835–1842 - 328 - ~1,500 - - -
Mexican-American War 1846–1848 78,718 1,733 11,550 13,283 4,152 - 71M, 1,801M
Third Seminole War 1855-1858 - 26 - 26 - - -
American Civil War - total 1861–1865 - 212,938 - ~625,000 - - -
American Civil War - Union - 2,200,000 140,414 224,097 364,511 281,881 - 3,183M, 45,199M
American Civil War -Confederate - 1,064,000 72,524 - ~260,000 - - 1,000M, 15,244M
Indian Wars 1865–1898 - 919 - - 1,025 - -
"Shinmiyangyo," Korean expedition 1871 - 3 - 3 9 - -
Spanish-American War6 1898 306,760 385 2,061 2,446 1,622 - 283M, 6,848M
Philippine-American War 1898–1902 - 1,020 3,176 4,196 2,930 - -
Boxer Rebellion 1900–1901 - 37 - 37 204 - -
Mexican Revolution 1914–1919 - 35+ - - 70 - -
US Occupation of Haiti 1915–1934 - 146 - - 26+ - -
World War I 1917–1918 4,734,991 53,402 63,114 116,516 204,002 3,350 20B, 253B
Northern Russian Expedition 1918-1920 - - - 424 - - -
China 1918; 1921; 1926-1927; 1930; 1937 - 5 - - 78 - -
US occupation of Nicaragua 1927-1933 - 48 - - 68 - -
World War II7 1941–1945 16,112,566 291,557 113,842 405,399 670,846 30,314 296B, 4,114B
China "Cold War" 1945-1947 - 13 - - 43 - -
Berlin Blockade 1948-1949 - - 31 - - - -
Korean War 1950–1953 5,720,000 33,746 ? 36,516 103,284 8,177 30B, 320B
Russia "Cold War" 1950-1955 - 32 - - 12 - -
China "Cold War" 1956 - 16 - - - - -
Bay of Pigs Invasion 1961 - 4 - - - - -
Vietnam War8 1957–1973 8,744,000 47,424 10,785 58,209 153,303 2,489 111B, 686B
"Operation Power Pack," Invasion of Dominican Republic 1965-1966 - 13 - - 200 - -
El Salvador Civil War 1980–1992 - 9 - 20 35 - -
"Multinational Force in Lebanon" - Beirut 1982–1984 - 256 - 266 169 - -
"Operation Earnest Will," Persian Gulf escorts 1987–1988 - 39 0 39 31 - 61B, 96B
Invasion of Grenada 1983 - 18 1 19 119 - -
Invasion of Panama 1989 - 23 - 40 324 - -
Persian Gulf War 1990–1991 2,225,000 148 151 299 467 - 61B, 96B
"Operation Restore Hope," Somalia 1992–1993 - 29 14 43 153 - -
"Operation Uphold Democracy," Haiti 1994–1995 - 1 - 4 3 - -
Bosnia-Herzegovina 1995-2004 - 1 - 12 6 - -
"1999 NATO bombing of the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia," Kosovo 1999-present - 1 19 20 2+ 0 -
"Operation Enduring Freedom," Afghanistan (still counting)9 2001–present - 402 209 611 2,379 - 159B, 171B
Iraq10, Afghan Wars (still counting) 2001–present - 3,643 540 4,183 43,797 1 809B, 859B
Global War on Terror 2001–present - - - - - - -


revolution_0

"Warfare is a form of communication, a primitive signaling strategy used to resolve disagreements - usually between peoples who speak different languages or think in incompatible ideological modes. It is expensive and notoriously inefficient." The Third Millennium, Ken Carey, Harper, 1995, p.113

NOTES/Discussion Points:

(1) Historically, we have thought of those wounded in war as physical wounds. However, through history, and it is becoming far better known about today, we also have those wounds of the psyche and the soul that translate to "psychological problems"... situations where there are no visible physical impairments, but render the warrior every bit as disabled and often unable to cope with work and/or society.

(2) From "Costs of Major U.S. Wars," Stephen Daggett, Congressional Research Service, Library of Congress, July 24, 2008

(3) All estimates are of the costs of military operations only and do not reflect costs of veterans benefits, interest on war-related debt, assistance to allies, etc., etc.

(4) Figures are in Current Year $, Constant FY2008$

(5) Per Wikipedia, all figures from the Revolutionary War are rounded estimates. Commonly cited casualty figures provided by the Department of Defense (VA) are 4,435 killed and 6,188 wounded, although the original government report that generated these numbers warned that the totals were incomplete and far too low. Nevertheless, the numbers are often repeated without this warning, such as on the United States Department of Veteran Affairs website. In 1974, historian Howard Peckham and a team of researchers came up with a total of 6,824 killed in action and 8,445 wounded. Because of incomplete records, Peckham estimated that this new total number of killed in action was still about 1,000 too low. Military historian John Shy subsequently estimated the total killed in action at 8,000, and argued that the number of wounded was probably far higher, about 25,000. The "other" deaths are primarily from disease, including prisoners who died on British prison ships.

(6) President McKinley told the American people that the USS Maine had been sunk in Havana Harbor by a Spanish mine. The American people, outraged by this apparent unprovoked attack, supported the Spanish American War. The Captain of the USS Maine had insisted the ship was sunk by a coal bin explosion, investigations after the war proved that such had indeed been the case. There had been no mine. Ref.: http://whatreallyhappened.com/WRHARTICLES/lieofthecentury.html.

(7) FDR claimed Pearl Harbor was a surprise attack. It wasn't. The United States saw war with Japan as the means to get into war with Germany, which Americans opposed. So Roosevelt needed Japan to appear to strike first. Following an 8-step plan devised by the Office of Naval Intelligence, Roosevelt intentionally provoked Japan into the attack. Contrary to the official story, the fleet did not maintain radio silence, but sent messages intercepted and decoded by US intercept stations. Tricked by the lie of a surprise attack, Americans marched off to war. Ref.: http://whatreallyhappened.com/WRHARTICLES/lieofthecentury.html AND http://www.independent.org/events/transcript.asp?eventID=28, in which "Day Of Deceit: The Truth About FDR and Pearl Harbor" is discussed by the author, Robert Stinnett.

(8) After-the-fact revelations about the rationale for the Vietnam War http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gulf of Tonkin Incident President Johnson lied about the Gulf of Tonkin to send Americans off to fight in Vietnam. The "second torpedo attack" that was the "cause celib" for the Vietnam War never took place, because the first such attack destroyed and disabled the only such armament that N. Vietnam had available. There were no torpedoes in the water in the Gulf. LBJ took advantage of an inexperienced sonar man's report to goad Congress into escalating the Vietnam War. Ref.: http://whatreallyhappened.com/WRHARTICLES/lieofthecentury.html.

(9) More fabrications, per http://www.commondreams.org/views01/1008-08.htm.

(10) The obvious lack of weapons of mass destruction in Iraq after the Second Gulf War shows how our own presidents have duped the American public into needless and completely unnecessary conflicts... using our military long before any of the pertinent facts had been established and a diplomatic process allowed to run its course... thereby resulting in heavy costs to the U.S. Additionally, the complete mismanagement of our "nation-building" efforts in Iraq following "Mission Accomplished," provides a whole textbook of examples of what NOT to do in attempting the reconstruction of a country. Ref.: http://whatreallyhappened.com/WRHARTICLES/lieofthecentury.html.




There are a surprising number of other websites that are tracking various aspects of war. Some examples:

http://www.antiwar.com/casualties/
http://www.nationalpriorities.org/costofwar_home
http://icasualties.org/oif/BY_DOD.aspx
http://www.americanfamilytraditions.com/war_casualties.htm
http://www.taphilo.com/history/war-deaths.shtml
http://aad.archives.gov/aad/
http://rationalrevolution.net/articles/casualties_of_war.htm
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_War_II_casualties
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_wars_and_disasters_by_death_toll


Go to top

Problems/Questions? Email us through here (webmaster@rv-vfp156.org)


Home | About Us | Activities | News/Info | The Costs of War | National & OR political contacts | Nuc Wpns Accidents | Nuc Wpns Abolition | Depleted Uranium |
The DD Form 4 | Opting Out | Straight Talk on Military Recruitment | Before You Enlist | Alternatives | G.I. Rights | Senior Vet Health Care | External Links