VFP Logo Rogue Valley Veterans for Peace
usaflag Chapter 156 peaceflag

"The most destructive decision that an individual can make is to give away his or her decision-making authority." The Third Millennium, Ken Carey, Harper, 1995, p.43


Menu


Home

About Us

Activities

News/Info

The Costs of War

National & OR political contacts

Nuc Wpns Accidents

Nuc Wpns Abolition

Depleted Uranium


Straight Talk on Military Recruitment

Opting Out

The Contract,
the current
DD Form 4

(.pdf format)


THIS PAGE IS:
Before You Enlist

Alternatives

G.I. Rights

External Links


Banner



Before You Enlist
Note that this is a long page, crammed with information and links
so that we have installed this menu for material following the "Introduction:"

Go to Introduction
Go to What They'll Never Tell You About Discharges... and the Veterans Administration Claims Process
Go to Military Recruitment Facts
Go to Understand the Enlistment Contract (and the DEP)
Go to Contract Tips & Warnings
Go to Modern Combat Training (a PTSD source?)
Go to Regulations & Culture
Go to Assignments/Family stresses
Go to Other Links

Introduction:

An eye-opening article, 75 Percent of Young Americans Unfit for Military, highlights a problem that the Army and Marines simply adjust to by changing their respective selection standards. During a period of an "economic draft," when the economy is not good enough to create or sustain jobs, these services can be as selective as the Air Force and Navy traditionally are. As proof of this, during a time before the current economic downturn, both the Army and Marines were, officially and unofficially (unofficially - when recruiters 'fudge' about applicants' medical and legal records, resulting in ex-gangbangers being court martialed for unwarranted civilian killings), waiving previously sacrosanct requirements.

According to a Veterans for Common Sense Factsheet, the U.S. has sent roughly 1.9 million troops to the MidEast wars (counting each reassignment as a "new troop" being sent) and, in addition to the 5,300 killed in action and 84,000 physical casualties, we are facing an estimated 700K soldiers coming home with varying levels of traumatic brain injuries (TBI) and post traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), which tears up families and, typically, often leaves the now-veteran with job related problems. These wars have resulted in considerably better survivability statistics, because 1) medical attention has been better than previous wars and 2) after Sec of Defense Rumsfeld and the Bush administration were forced to do so, the troops in the field were provided with better armor. This has resulted in fewer KIA, but a far higher number of disabilities, including what used to be known (since our Revolutionary War) as "shell shock."

Now, looking at the Chart on our The Cost of War page, we can see that, since our own Revolution, we have been in a "new" declared war, on average, about every 5-1/2 years, often, as in the Iraq/Afganistan situation, without final resolution of an existing/on-going war. Consolidating this information, how have we ever been able to sustain the growth this country has experienced when we loose so many of our best men to wars? That is a topic that can only be addressed in book form, looking at our physical expansion, our technology expansion based on drawing the "cream of the crop" from other nations and the addition to our GNP as a result of various corporations' profits from a war economy and because, ever since 1812, we have never had to fight a war on our own soil.

So, before you enlist, look at our The Cost of War page and this YouTube video made by another organization of active duty soldiers recent vets, and consider that the vast majority of our wars were/are being conducted for commercial interests. Then ask yourself if that's what you want to fight for.

There are two easy-to-read, short books you need to read through before you decide to enlist. One is "Addicted to War" by Joel Andreas (copies are contributed by this Chapter to those schools that participate in the classroom presentations of our 'Straight Talk' Program) and the other is "10 Excellent Reasons Not To Join The Military" edited by Elizabeth Weill-Greenberg.

Actually, as usual, Beetle Bailey (below) captures a key factor in military life...

Go to top


What They'll Never Tell You About Discharges... and the Veterans Administration Claims Process:

Perhaps this section should be in another webpage entitled "The VA - After You Get Out," but we feel it is important to know some of this before you sign your life away in the short term.
1) Your options with respect to "getting out" are far wider than you'd be presented with either by recruiters or while in you're the military. This chart provides a list of the most common kinds of discharge (beyond the Honorable, General and Dishonorable that you'll be indoctrinated with). Note that the Conscientious Objector category occupies the last three pages. While only a handful of these have been granted, the Army and Marines have seen a landslide of them after their members experienced the less-than-idealized combat situations in the Middle East. Both Army and Marine troops have found that they have not been trained for that kind of warfare, and that the tactics they have been taught simply alienate the local population.

2) Military CBPOs (Central Base Personnel Offices, or simply "Personnel" - but which may be called something different in different service branches and bases) really do make mistakes on the DD-214 that governs your post-military experiences and the access you might have to any benefits, including the VA! This can take various forms (as noted in this article), but typically is in the form of mistaken references on the DD 214 (check the code on your DD 214 number!).

3) The VA does not have a direct link-up to any DoD database (as the local recruiters have to get you INTO the service), so that it is up to the service member to prove his own eligibility for benefits, while attempting to wade through 8 pages of VA Forms at http://www4.va.gov/vaforms/. The first application is typically disapproved, so there is a standard 19-page appeals procedure that we have found on the VA website, provided here in large-file (almost 4MB) ".pdf" format Pamphlet 01-02-02A.
A "60 Minutes show on January 3, 2010, revealed the following about the Veterans Administration bureaucracy (even though the VA is supposed to process a claim in 30 days or less!): 1) They have been processing over 400K claims since 2003;
2) They currently have about a 1M claim backlog;
3) In 2009, they paid out over $1B in claims;
4) The current claim form is 23 pages!;
5) Upon the initial claim submittal, vets have to wait about 6 months and are then typically denied their claim (remember, it is up to the vet to prove his own claim);
6) After initial denial, the resubmission review can easily take another four years!;
7) VA employees have no incentive to approve or disprove claims, but only "earn points" in how many they "process;"
8) Therefore, these VA employees don't have the time to read through the volumes of materials that are typically submitted by the veteran (as required by the process to prove the claim), therefore,
9) about 1/4 of these files have errors.

And then to supplement the above...
10) According to MSNBC's Rachael Maddow Show on January 25, 2010, the VA call center (the initial contact between the veteran and the VA) has been "downsized" to only being operational between Mondays and Wednesdays, from 7 AM to 5 PM Central Standard time. Their own info shows that over 90% of vets have not been able to connect!

11) Similar to the way Agent Orange of Vietnam fame, and several other similar situations, the VA is now being forced by court order to comply with the kind of veterans support they have been supposed to be doing all along!
See this MS Word document Vets With PTSD May Get Benefits Upgrade.

12) Veterans and Mesothelioma: Currently, the U.S. Department of Veteran Affairs recognizes mesothelioma as a service-connected medical condition.
Due to common military practices (... and how many veterans medical problems is this an excuse for??), veterans who served between 1940 and 1970 have a great risk of developing asbestos-related illnesses. Additionally, Navy personnel and workers employed in shipyards from the 1930s through the 1970s hold a greater risk of developing a disease caused by asbestos exposure.
However, even if a veteran has been diagnosed with mesothelioma (of which nearly 100 percent of all cases are caused by asbestos exposure), the VA may not approve their claim for disability compensation - unless the veteran can provide evidence that their mesothelioma is as likely as not to have been caused by exposure to asbestos while in service.
Yes, we know that the virtually glacial VA application process can be very hard to endure when you're in pain... no matter what kind of pain... and that there have been several Gulf War veteran suicides during this process (even as there were 58K KIA in Vietnam but 150K active duty and veteran suicides). However, once you're "in the system" things can get better!!! (Within our Chapter, we have one Vietnam USAF veteran that finally received his 100% disability from the VA late in 2008 - he had a pretty rough time up to that point - so that he may be able to finally fully retire.)
Go to top

Military Recruitment Facts:

Why might you find this topic on a veterans website??? Because we've all been through it and can attest to the discrepancies between what recruiters tell the potential recruit and what actual military life is all about: Ref. http://www.objector.org/before-you-enlist/recruiter-letter.html (an Army recruiter's conflicts between the Army Times vs. what he is supposed to tell potential recruits). For a few suggestions look over this short 3-page document, The Truth About What Recruiters Promise.doc, or this 19-page document Questions for Military Recruiters - and The Answers They Should Give You.doc. To portray a worst-case, but realistic, idea of what the new recruit might encounter, we have "borrowed" a very well-done resource guide assembled by the Veterans for Peace, Chapter 56 (Humboldt Bay), entitled "Advice From Veterans on Military Service and Recruitment Practices" in (.pdf) format.
We also do whatever we can to assist veterans.


(The following has been modified/updated from: http://www.vfp-northcountry.org/b4enlist/b4enlist.php)

1. Recruiters often lie. According the New York Times, nearly one of five United States Army recruiters was under investigation in 2004 for offenses varying from "threats and coercion to false promises that applicants would not be sent to Iraq." One veteran recruiter told a reporter for the Albany (NY) Times Union, "I've been recruiting for years, and I don't know one recruiter who wasn't dishonest about it. I did it myself."
On the other hand, many recruiters are under a great deal of stress to "produce," i.e., "keep the numbers up," as can be attested to in this very graphic article, in December 2008, 4 recruiter suicides lead to Army investigation.

2. The military contract guarantees nothing and the Department of Defense's own enlistment/re-enlistment document states that in Sec. 9.b. of the current DD Form 4, a ".pdf" copy of the enlistment contract that most recruiters use but don't want you to study too much before you sign.

3. Advertised signing bonuses are bogus. Bonuses are often thought of as gifts, but they're not. They're like loans: If an enlistee leaves the military before his or her agreed term of service, he or she will be forced to repay the bonus. Plus, Army data shows that the top bonus of $20,000 was given to only 6 percent of the 47,7272 enlistees who signed up for active duty.

4. The military won't make you financially secure. Military members are no strangers to financial strain: 48 percent report having financial difficulty, approximately 33 percent of homeless men in the United States are veterans, and nearly 200,000 veterans are homeless on any given night.
Perhaps one of the best measures of the economic impact of joining the military is the analysis of whether a person who enters the military, on average, earns more or less than a comparable non-veteran. In a comprehensive overview of 14 studies which analyzed this question, Stephen R. Barley of the School of Industrial and Labor Relations at Cornell Univrsiy found that the average post-Vietnam War-era veteran will earn between 11% (Crane and Wise, 1987) and 19% (Rosen and Taubman, 1982) less than non-veterans from comparable socioeconomic backgrounds. According to a 1990 study by Bryant and Wilhite, the average veteran will earn about $2,800 less per year in 2008 dollars (after adjustment for inflation effects) than nonveteran peers. [http://www.objector.org/before-you-enlist/myths.html]
Also, see if your recruiter can tell you how many military pereonnel are currently on food stamps. If he says "None," run, don't just walk, out of that recruiting office.

5. Money for college ($71,424 in the bank?). While the new post-9/11 G.I. Bill offers some promise, if you expect the military to pay for college, better read the fine print. The Montgomery GI Bill was designed for recruitment, not to meet college expenses as the post-WWII G.I. Bill was. Among recruits who sign up for the Montgomery GI Bill, 65 percent receive no money for college, and only 15 percent ever receive a college degree. The maximum Montgomery GI Bill benefit is $37,224, and even this 37K is hard to get: To join, you must first put in a nonrefundable $1,200 deposit that has to be paid to the military during the first year of service. To receive the $37K, you must also be an active-duty member who has completed at least a three-year service agreement and is attending a four-year college full time.
Benefits are significantly lower if you are going to school part-time or attending a two-year college. If you receive a less than honorable discharge (as one in four do), leave the military early (as one in three do), or later decide not to go to college, the military will keep your Montgomery GI Bill deposit and give you nothing. Note: The $71,424 advertised by the Army and $86,000 by the Navy includes benefits from the Amy or Navy College Fund, respectively. Fewer than 10 percent of all recruits earn money from the Army College Fund, which is specifically designed to lure recruits into hard-to-fill positions.

6. Job training. Vice President Dick Cheney once said, "The military is not a social welfare agency; it's not a jobs program." (Of course, this is from someone who exercised all the draft deferments he could to stay out of the military - at the time of the draft - yet has the audacity to call for military deployment and fighting long before all international diplomatic resources have been exhausted!) If you enlist, the military does not have to place you in your chosen career field or give you the specific training requested. Even if enlistees do receive training, it is often to develop skills that will not transfer to the civilian job market. (There aren't many jobs for M240 machine-gunners, for those trained to test and maintain nuclear weapons, etc.)

7. War, combat, and your contract. First off, if it's your first time enlisting, you're signing up for eight years (between active and reserve time). On top of that, the military can, without your consent, extend active-duty obligations during times of conflict, "national emergency," or when directed by the president. This means that even if an enlistee has two weeks left on his/ her contract (yes, even Guard/Reserve) or has already served in combat, she/he can still be sent to war. Look closely at the contract, the DD Form 4.
More than a dozen U.S. soldiers have challenged 'stop-loss' measures like these in court so far, but people continue to be shipped off involuntarily. The military has called thousands up from Inactive Ready Reserve (see next Section) -- soldiers who have served, some for as long as a decade, and been discharged. The numbers: twice as many troops are fighting in Iraq and Afghanistan per year as during the Vietnam War. One-third of the troops who have gone to Iraq have gone more than once. The highest rate of first-time deployments belongs to the Marine Corps Reserve: almost 90 percent have fought."
In a quote by retired General Wesley K. Clark, Sunday, December 21, 2008, in the Washington Post: "The military must obey the orders of the commander in chief and follow the chain of command, which means giving up one's own liberties and spending time in difficult and often very dangerous circumstances."


Go to top


Understand the Enlistment Contract You Are Signing!!!

The enlistment contract for active duty military members is actually made up of two separate contracts (a copy of the current 2007 DD-4, typically used by all services and more detailed than the 2001 version), which recruiters do not normally give to you in time for you to actually read through it to see what you are getting into. The first part of the contract you will sign applies to the Delayed Enlistment Program (DEP), which includes the inactive reserves. All active duty members sign this contract and are members of the DEP. However, if you have signed up for the DEP, you need to understand that, before you are actually sworn in and ship out, you can back out of the contract with absolutely minimal consequences. Understand, before you are sworn in, because the Reserve and Guard may swear you in "on the spot," which places you in the military.

  • If you're signing up for active duty, the contract most important to you is the one for active duty. Its terms will apply to your situation, and anything not included in that contract will not be honored or enforced. Be VERY careful of Block 8, since, at first glance, 8/a/b/c all apply to the same situation, but they do not!

  • Carefully read the first part of the contract that lists all of your obligations to the military and all of the consequences to you if you do not honor these obligations. A clause of the contract (Section 9.b.) points out that some laws which apply directly to you, including those regarding status, pay, allowances, benefits, responsibilities, etc., may be changed without notice to you. This is allowed under the contract.

  • Grasp the fact that the contract allows for changes in the length of your enlistment in the case of war. Section 10 covers these changes. During the course of your enlistment, if the U.S. goes to war, the military reserves the right to extend your enlistment for however long it deems appropriate (stop loss).

  • Realize that the enlistment contract for first-time members of the military actually applies for a period of eight years. Those eight years can be spent on active duty, in the active Reserves or National Guard or in the inactive reserves. (You can read this in Paragraph 10(a) of the contract.) This Individual Ready Reserve (IRR), sometimes called the Inactive Ready Reserve, is composed of former military personnel who still have time remaining on their enlistment agreements but have returned to civilian life - this includes all retired military personnel!.

    Yet, of those of us who are "eligible" to be called up in such "states of emergency," many have found a way to resist. (As of the end of 2008, the Army had about 118,000 personnel in this category, but could not "find" about 40,000.) Download this Courage to Resist Feb 3, '09 [PDF leaflet], Resisting Recall from the Individual Ready Reserve.
Go to top



Contract Tips & Warnings
  • Be sure you understand the contract! Find someone to explain it to you if you do not. This contract lists ALL of your rights and obligations, and you want to make sure you understand it.

  • Know that all branches of the military, except the Marine Corps and the Coast Guard, offer a college loan repayment program in their enlistment contracts. Be sure to find out whether this program applies to your particular college loan, because it does not apply to all of them. Understand the differences between the Montgomery GI Bill and the Post-9/11 GI Bill (which fully kicks in after August, '09).

  • If you accept the College Fund bonus, under the "old" Montgomery GI Bill, it will reduce your enlistment bonus. Most of the College Fund money you get through enlistment is available to you anyway through the "new" G.I. Bill. You do not need to apply for the College Fund in order to be eligible for this money. The contract makes no mention of this fact.

  • Because of Section 8.c. and 9.b., be sure to get a full Annex to Section 8, not just 8.a. or 8.b.

Go to top


Modern Combat Training

Modern Combat Training conditions soldiers to act reflexively to stimuli and this maximizes soldiers’ lethality, but it does so by bypassing their moral autonomy. Soldiers are conditioned to act without considering the moral repercussions of their actions; they are enabled to kill without making the conscious decision to do so. If they are unable to justify to themselves the fact that they killed another human being, they will likely — and understandably — suffer enormous guilt. This guilt manifests itself as post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), and it has damaged the lives of thousands of men who performed their duty in combat.” — Lt. Colonel Peter Kilner, Professor of Philosophy and Ethics, West Point Military Academy
Note: This "modern combat training" methodology came about when studies showed that only about 10% to 25% of WWII combat personnel actually fired at the "enemy." The new approach, which showed up with higher kill rates in Vietnam, is to train to fire much faster, which has "improved" the rate of firing has increased to about 95%. BUT the end result can be lethal for civilians and the soldier that does the firing can be traumatized for life, because "In the wars of the 1990s, civilian deaths constituted between 75% and 90% of all war deaths" (quote from "What Every Person Should Know About War" by Chris Hedges).

Also understand that physical disability as a result of combat is only the "tip of the iceburg." Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), known as "shell shock" in past wars and resulting in terrific trauma to the individual and his/her immediate family, is slowly becoming more talked about and sometimes treatable, depending upon its individualized severity. It is estimated that over 27% of our combat troops are experiencing this trauma (revised upward from the previous figure of 20%, per VA statistics) and there are even high-ranking officers that have personally experienced its effects, such as discussed in these MS Word files, Army Maj. Gen. David Blackledge and 4-Star Gen. Carter Ham .

Go to top


Regulations & Culture

Understand that Every procedure in the military is directed by a regulation. The Department of Defense (DoD) issues "Directives" and "Instructions" that establish general policies for all of the Services: the Army, Navy, Marine Corps, and Air Force. (The Marine Corps, which we refer to as a Service, is actually a part of the Navy. The Coast Guard, while only a part of the DoD during times of war, also follows DoD policy regarding discharges.)

"The Services implement DoD policies with their own, often differing, regulations based on their own unique traditions and policies. The Army issues "Regulations," the Navy, Air Force, and Coast Guard issue "Instructions," and the Marine Corps issues "Orders." The result is literally thousands of regulations.

"The sheer number of military regulations is overwhelming, not just for civilian outsiders but often to commanders as well. It is not unusual for the practices at a unit to contradict regulatory policy. In such cases, citing regulatory policy to a client's commander can result in a unit following proper procedures when processing a client.

"More commonly, military regulations are so ambiguous, or allow for such broad command discretion, that they do not provide concrete policy guidance. However, even in such situations knowledge of military regulations can add greatly to a counselor's credibility with a commander. Arguments based on regulations, even when the regulations are vague, will carry more weight."

Also understand that, within each service, there are prejudices that can enhance or limit a person's advancement. The "enhancing professions" within the three main services:

  • Within the Navy (including the Marines), submariners, SEALs and pilots have the "inside track" on promotions.
  • Within the Army, its the Green Berets and other Special Forces (whatever titles they go under at the time).
  • Within the Air Force (and I can attest to this on a first-hand basis - Don Chapin, VFP156), it's pilots of fighters, then bombers, then cargo planes, then navigators.

Also if, in any of the services, you work for a performance rating civilian (who typically has no idea of how inflated the rating systems historically are) then your chances of promotion take another major "hit." And if you happen to be female, expect repeated sexual attempts and, possibly, some attacks. Ref: http://www.alternet.org/story/35792/ and many other similar accounts. Another drawback within the commissioned ranks is having too much enlisted time (with very few exceptions)... up to about three years is "acceptable," but anything beyond that is generally a "negative" to officer review boards.

However, some of us can also attest to the fact that there can be benefits to a military enlistment (once you make it past what some of us see as the traumas of boot camp :-), but you have to be careful and often search them out yourself.
Examples - by Don Chapin, VFP156:

(1) I was being extremely bitter about the military during my first three years in service due to what I saw - as many others have - the lies from my recruiter. This open bitterness delayed my third stripe until after I re-enlisted on a gamble to try taking advantage of a very little-known education and commissioning program. I succeeded and earned a B.S. and M.S. in engineering while still in uniform (this also resulted in a "demotion" from an E-5 to an O-1 :-). This kind of program is typically not internally advertised within the services, but each one has its own version.
(2) My eldest son, who no longer wanted me to help him negotiate with the Army recruiters when he found out he could get a six-week fire-fighting course (but "only" with a six-year commitment - HA!), finally did take my advice to volunteer for anything and everything he could. While he failed the tests for OCS, he came out as a fire fighter and a jump-qualified paramedic, and married to a parachute packer from his last duty station.

Go to top

Assignments/Family stresses - from: http://usmilitary.about.com/cs/joiningup/a/recruiter1_2.htm
"The average Navy enlisted person can spend a significant amount of time each year at sea. On any given day, 40 percent of Navy personnel are assigned to a ship or submarine, and 35 to 45 percent of those ships will be deployed to sea (2003 statistics). Depending on your Air Force AFSC (job), and duty assignment, you may find yourself spending up to seven months out of every year deployed to such garden spots as Kosovo, Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, Afghanistan, or Iraq. The Army deploys a significant amount of folks to beautiful downtown Iraq, Afghanistan, Bosnia and Kosovo. The Marines are also scattered around (although not in as great numbers as the other services). Recently, however, the Marines have been taking their turn in Iraq and Afghanistan. However, unlike the Army (and like the Navy), a Marine may find him/herself spending significants amount of time deployed to sea on Navy and Marine Ships. Even if you elect to join the National Guard or Reserves, these branches now spend a significant amount of time deployed to areas such as Iraq, Afghanistan, Bosnia, Kosovo, and the Gulf."

And from http://usmilitary.about.com/od/joiningthemilitary/a/recruiterlies_3.htm
"All of your retirement pay may not belong to you. If you were married at any time during your military service, under the Uniformed Services Former Spouse Protection Act, any state divorce court can treat your current or future retirement pay as "community property" and award a portion of it to your ex-spouse. Considering 50 percent of military marriages end up in divorce, this is something to keep in mind."

Go to top


Other Links:

http://www.resistersbook.org/ (From Warriors to Resisters)

http://www.objector.org/index.html (Central Committee for Conscientious Objections supports and promotes individual and collective resistance to war and preparations for war.A comprehensive website covering many aspects of enlistment and becoming a conscientious objector.)

http://www.objector.org/before-you-enlist/recruiter-letter.html (An Army recruiter's conflicts between the Army Times vs. what he is supposed to tell potential recruits…. also here in MSWord format.)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6fkkdoDOIJM&eurl=http://www.beforeyouenlist.org/index.htm (Before You Enlist, a very good video)

A few of the many documented recruiter problems:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7BFNKzmqHjs&feature=related and http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zbFPaknBOgQ&feature=related

(Hidden cameras catch Army recruiters)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xkHTYfqwooE&feature=related (Army Recruiters Tell Applicant to Lie and Cheat)

http://www.objector.org/helpingout/description.html (A Guide to Military Discharges and GI Rights)

http://www.alternet.org/story/35792/ (For women, in particular, "An Excellent Reason Not to Join the Military")

http://www.afsc.org/Youth&Militarism/ ("The AFSC is directed by a Quaker board and staffed by Quakers and other people of faith who share the Friends' desire for peace and social justice." While some of their information is potentially a bit more negative against military promises and enlistment than many of us might go to, they do have some very good materials.)

Go to top

Note- You'll need the current version of the Acrobat Reader to view and print the materials.
If you don't have it already, then : Click on the Adobe Reader to download.


A bumper sticker quote:
"Why suffer from insanity when you can revel in it?
Join the military"

Problems/Questions? Email us through here (webmaster@rv-vfp156.org)


Home | About Us | Activities | News/Info | The Costs of War | National & OR political contacts | Nuc Wpns Accidents | Nuc Wpns Abolition |
Depleted Uranium | The DD Form 4 | Opting Out | Straight Talk on Military Recruitment | Before You Enlist | Alternatives | G.I. Rights | External Links